David Bingham

The opener for Audio Language, a sound program I led for GE Appliances between 2011 and 2014. It sets up the question the page answers: how a brand that is seen and touched can also be heard, across four appliance lines.

The top half of a circular brand board around the GE monogram, with value words such as Honest, Reliable and Thoughtful ringed by photographs of furniture, a car, a castle, a coffee maker and a restaurant.

Audio Language

Auditory appliance experiences grounded in brand and interaction.

Problem statement

My own framing of the brief, lifted from my 2018 presentation. Sound in a kitchen is a utility that lets cooks keep their attention on the work and calls for it only when needed, and at home it can add delight and a sense of control. I set out the problem as extending an established product experience into a new sense, with a team of consumer insights, industrial, interaction and sound designers.

With consumer product experiences becoming increasingly rich, the GE Appliances concept and brand team asked how we should consider our products' auditory expression. Within numerous kitchen activities, sound is a utility that allows cooks to maintain focus on their craft then request their attention as needed. For families in less professional environments, sound can add an element of delight in alerts and a subtle reinforcement of control interactions. How do we create a language that meaningfully extends a well-established product experience? In this landscape, the team of consumer insights, industrial, interaction, and sound designers approached the problem through the lens of appliance interactions and brand impression.

The problem that made the work hard, in my words. Industrial designers had image boards and material samples to critique against; sound had nothing like that, so the method had to give a team a way to critique what it could not see.

A kitchen with a stainless side-by-side refrigerator, a professional range under a steel hood, white subway tile, dark cabinets and a marble island holding plates and a bowl of pears.
1. How to inform and inspire the design of an aligned auditory experience?
2. How can the team provide critique to a non-visual design process?
A grid of photograph tiles on white: food, headphones, a wristwatch, a camera, an espresso machine, a tape dispenser, knives, a synthesizer and people cooking together.

Research survey

The brand research reduced to one informal survey question, asked of all four brands at once. Framing a brand as a car, a restaurant, a clothing store or a drink gave people a way to talk about character without musical vocabulary, and asking the four together made the comparison between them useful.

A spreadsheet of survey answers in four color bands, one per brand logo, with columns for car, Saturday night restaurant, clothing store and drink of choice.
Informal research survey results

What if <brand> were a…
…car?
…restaurant?
…clothing store?
…drink?

Research workshops

The conceptual framework beside a wall from the second research workshop. Four concentric rings, brand, values, cues, and artifacts, gave the team a structure for describing each brand's character in images, and the Monogram wall shows it in use, with value notes such as Minimal, Craftsmanship, and Timeless above grids of pinned photographs. The second workshop widened the group to participants from marketing, product management, and engineering.

Four concentric circles labeled brand, values, cues and artifacts from the center outward, with a short definition of each term in the lower left.
Conceptual framework
A wall poster headed Monogram, with yellow value notes such as Minimal, Craftsmanship and Timeless across the top and printed photographs pinned in grids under Design Elements and Lifestyle headings.

The four bullseye boards from the first research workshop, one per brand, each with value words on yellow notes at the center and printed photographs of products, food, and cars placed around them. The workshop was a dry run with the internal design team to test the framework, and it showed that the verbal debate was as valuable as the resulting map and that each brand needed an antithesis category.

A concentric-circle poster on a wall with yellow notes reading Basics, Fun, Retro and Mac and Cheese at the center and printed photographs of products and food pinned around them.
A concentric-circle poster with yellow notes reading Reliable, Purposeful, Honest, American and Thoughtful at the center, ringed by photographs of sedans, pies, a camera and a Coca-Cola bottle.
A concentric-circle poster with yellow notes reading Professional, State of the art, Precise, Aspirational, Confident and Robust around the center, ringed by photographs of espresso machines, mixers and plated food.
A concentric-circle poster with yellow notes reading Performance, Trust, Luxury, Craftsmanship, Timeless, Status, Custom, Integrated and Minimal, ringed by black-and-white photographs of cameras, cars and wine.

Four brand bullseyes, one each for Artistry, GE, Café and Monogram: radial maps of cues, values and artifacts such as colors, materials, form and rooms of the home. They gave the team an abstraction to argue about a brand without arguing about a sound, and they are the brand set every later block depends on.

A circular brand board in gray around the GE monogram, its inner ring of words such as Vibrant, Youthful and Practical, its outer rings of photographs including a red coffee maker, a Volkswagen Beetle, a drum kit and Pabst Blue Ribbon.
GE Artistry Brand
A circular brand board in blue around the GE monogram, its inner ring of words such as Honest, Reliable and Family, its outer rings of photographs including a Jeep, a Gap storefront, Cinderella Castle and a clarinet.
GE Brand
A circular brand board in red around the GE monogram, its inner ring of words such as Precise, Robust and Bold, its outer rings of photographs including a Land Rover, a watch movement, a tuning fork and cups of cocoa.
GE Café Brand
A circular brand board in purple around the Monogram wordmark, its inner ring of words such as Craftsmanship, Sophisticated and Timeless, its outer rings of photographs including a BMW, a Rolex, a grand piano and champagne glasses.
GE Monogram Brand

Soundtrack

The two goals behind the soundtrack work: inform and inspire the design of an aligned auditory experience, and help the team critique a non-visual design process. The answer was to critique a single score rather than many disparate sounds, then derive the interaction sounds from the soundtrack's instrumentation.

Goals

Soundtracks > Interaction Sounds

1. Inform and inspire the design of an aligned auditory experience. 2. Help the team provide critique to a non-visual design process. Critique a single score rather than numerous disparate sounds. Soundtrack instrumentation then derives interaction sounds for a system of auditory feedback.

The four brand soundtracks, composed by David Chow to my brief, with the rationale I gave in an interview in November 2012. Each brand was given a band or an instrument: garage-band guitar and drums for Artistry, a reserved track for Café so the burners' clicks and the door could carry the brand, airy woodwinds for GE after an acoustic Midwestern direction was dropped, and a luxurious piano for Monogram. The soundtrack came first; the interaction sounds were derived from it.

Artistry

The challenge for developing an audio identity for the Hotpoint brand was understanding where the business wants to take the brand. The brand position is retro, youthful, sensible style. The sound profile we developed has a garage band feel to it, featuring guitar distortion and drums.

Café

The Café brand is all about restaurant-inspired appliances with a professional look and feel. So for the audio we took a more reserved approach, to allow the gas burners' 'clicks' and the solid door closing sound to take more prominence.

GE

The GE brand is really all about living innovation. It's purposeful, modern and authentic. It was one of the most difficult to pin down because of the legacy of the brand. We started with a thought of 'American' and 'familiarity', which lead to an acoustic guitar lead, Midwestern feel. While it was honest and thoughtful, it didn't feel inspired and forward looking. That's when we switched to airy woodwinds backed with an uneven cadence that carries a feeling of innovation. I think what we achieved is a sound language that's Aaron Copeland inspired, forward looking and strong.

Monogram

When you look at GE's Monogram line, you're seeing exceptional craftsmanship and sophistication. When we were looking at a musical instrument that people associate with those qualities, we thought of the piano. The audio for Monogram has an intensity to it — it's not a lazy lounge piano sound, but more luxurious, with an intent.

The complete vocabulary: nineteen functions across four brands, seventy-six sounds, every one playable with its 2013 definition. The rows are grouped into interactions the user makes and passive alerts the product makes, and the shared duration scale lets the four brands be compared like for like. This grid is what the project was for.

Function · design intentArtistryGECaféMonogram

Interact

Touch

Basic tone generically used to denote an interface interaction.

0.15s0.33s0.23s0.33s

Unavailable Touch

The product is in a cycle or state that disallows the particular control.

0.18s0.31s0.34s0.42s

Select

A confirming tone to let the user know of a successful interaction (opposite Cancel).

0.23s0.50s0.38s0.50s

Cancel

A slightly negative or unsuccessful tone (opposite Select).

0.24s0.31s0.23s0.61s

Increase

Adjust a value or control magnitude up (opposite Decrease).

0.23s0.31s0.32s0.46s

Decrease

Adjust a value or control magnitude down (opposite Increase).

0.21s0.31s0.33s0.48s

On

Accompanies a product function being turned on (opposite Off).

0.64s0.84s0.42s0.81s

Off

Accompanies a product function being turned off (opposite On).

0.64s0.81s0.56s0.96s

Press & Hold On

Similar to On, this sound emphasizes the extended interaction and engaging a feature.

0.80s0.99s1.00s1.50s

Press & Hold Off

Similar to Function On, this sound emphasizes the extended interaction and engaging a feature.

1.07s0.97s0.96s1.50s

Power On

The product's startup tone to confirm operational.

1.62s1.68s2.84s3.33s

Power Off

The product's shut-down tone.

1.85s1.97s2.11s1.92s

Passive

Alarm Low

The least urgent alarm sound that loops to get people's attention.

1.66s2.12s2.27s2.08s

Alarm Mid

A looping, moderate priority sound to call people to the product.

1.66s1.65s1.86s2.36s

Alarm Urgent

A looping, highly urgent sound to get people's attention immediately.

2.48s2.37s1.48s1.78s

Notification

A single event notifying the user to perform periodic maintenance or other product needs.

1.59s0.87s1.63s2.79s

Cycle Pre

Related to Cycle Complete hinting at an immanent process completion.

0.69s0.92s1.19s1.10s

Cycle Complete

Plays once when a process cycle is complete.

1.45s1.70s1.84s1.97s

Cycle Post

A patient, ongoing tone after Cycle Complete to remind that the process is over.

0.76s0.88s0.87s1.24s

Control specifications

The GE electric range control panel with every button mapped to the sound file it plays, such as GE_Interact_Touch.wav. Specifying sounds against real control artwork validated and refined the interaction sounds, and these documents briefed the team that built the HTML prototypes.

The GE Electric Range control panel drawn in black, with blue leader lines from each button to labels naming the sound file it plays, such as GE_Interact_Touch.wav, and a pink note asking for a start sound.
GE Electric Range

Prototypes

Three ways the team heard the sounds in context: a stove with a touchscreen backsplash, one of fourteen HTML control simulators showing the GE range panel with its sound names, and gestural controls on an iPad. The simulators, one for each product category and brand, were far faster to change than flashing appliance firmware or building hardware controls.

A large touchscreen showing an oven control with a rotary knob, standing behind a white foam-board cabinet with a laptop on its shelf, in a model shop.
Stove with touchscreen backsplash
A browser window showing the GE Range control panel drawn as a black strip of buttons, with a two-row grid of sound names such as touch, select and alarmurgent below it.
14 HTML-based control simulators
A hand touching an iPad in a dark room; the screen shows two arc-shaped dials with power symbols and plus and minus marks on a purple background.
Gestural controls on an iPad

Speaker enclosures

The speaker definition: the part, its frequency response and circuitry, with photographs of the 3D-printed enclosure mock-ups. The decision that mattered was to commonize, one speaker platform across product lines rather than one per program.

A small gray plastic housing opened to show a green speaker cone, a red LED, a slide switch and a circuit board joined by colored wires.
Dissassembled small audio devices
A frequency response chart, sound pressure from 50 to 110 decibels against frequency from 20 to 20,000 hertz, its line rising to a plateau near 85 decibels with peaks around 600 and 3,500 hertz.
Sound file playback frequencies
Pink foam blocks on a dark desk, several holding small round speakers, beside a page of pen sketches of an enclosure in section labeled gasket and support posts.
Enclosure volume studies
The cooling fan and nozzle of a 3D printer in a dark enclosure, above two white plastic enclosure parts being printed on the bed.
3D printed test speaker enclosures

My diagram of the audio reproduction chain: instrument, recording, storage, conversion, amplification, transmission, speaker and environment, with quality lost at every stage. It turned a vague complaint that the sound was wrong into a question with eight places to look.

A left-to-right chain of icons labeled Musician, Instrument, Recording, Storage, Conversion, Amplification, Transmission, Speaker, Environment and Listener, each with a one-line definition beneath.
Sequential influences to audio reproduction quality

Within appliances

Opens the Speakers section with my account of testing sound inside real appliances. We disassembled a dishwasher, a refrigerator and a range, installed speakers and wired them to an external amplifier for quick iteration and to the internal control with flashed firmware for true playback through the product electronics.

To test how the appliance cavity and electronics would impact sound quality, we disassembled a dishwasher, refrigerator, and range. The speakers were installed and wired to both internal and external sources. The external amplifier wiring could playback sounds from any source for quick iteration. The second source was to the internal control with flashed firmware. While not as quick and flexible as the external wiring, this allowed playback of true control patterns through the actual product electronics.

The speaker test photographed inside a top-control dishwasher door, with the callouts from my 2022 deck: two test speakers, wiring to the internal control and wiring to an external amplifier. It shows how far from the studio the sounds had to work, inside an insulated steel door. The same test appears in Unified Controls, which used these sounds.

A small test speaker fixed to the top rail inside a dishwasher door, with red and black wires running across the insulation to the control.123
A close view of a small black box-shaped speaker mounted under the top rail inside the door.1
Test Speaker 1
A close view of a small rectangular speaker with an oval black cone, held to the rail by two mounting ears.2
Test Speaker 2
A close view of two white connectors at the top right of the door, a bundle of brown, white, yellow and green wires from one, and a pair of red and black leads running to a loose white connector below.3
Wiring to Internal Control (above) and Wiring to External Amplifier (below); inside a top control dishwasher door

Design framework

The four steps I set for the program: explore the brands, define and consolidate the technical functions, design the sounds, then gather feedback and iterate. The order matters: the brand work and the function list came before any composer was engaged. The image slot is for the first version of the sound framework.

A concept map linking Events, Emotions and Sound Qualities by arrows, with event types such as Interaction, Notification and Alert, sound qualities such as Pitch, Rhythm and Timbre, overlapping user and brand circles, and four yellow notes numbered 1 to 4 describing each step.

Implementation guide

The IDO Sound Guide, version 2.5, dated August 9, 2013, open on its cover, with the full PDF linked for download. It documented the sound library and how to implement and extend it, with the sounds embedded for playback in context, and was published internally for the design, product management, engineering, advertising and public relations, and web and app teams.

Press coverage

Two articles from 2012 as they appeared: Co.Design's "GE's New Emphasis In Appliances: Sound Design," dated December 6, 2012, and the Wall Street Journal's "The Search for Sweet Sounds That Sell" by Ellen Byron, dated October 24, 2012. They show the program drew attention in the design and business press more than a year before the Monogram dishwasher shipped in February 2014.

A Co.Design article page headlined GE's New Emphasis In Appliances: Sound Design, dated December 6, 2012, with an engraved illustration of the inner ear.
Co.Design, 2012
A Wall Street Journal article page headlined The Search for Sweet Sounds That Sell, by Ellen Byron, October 24, 2012, with a related video about a vacuum cleaner.
The Wall Street Journal, 2012

The coverage: GE Appliances' 2013 press release announcing the Monogram dishwasher as the first appliance with its own soundtrack, then the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal, Co.Design, GE Reports and insideGE. The press is here as corroboration that the work shipped and was noticed.

The Washington Post

Newspaper · 2013

GE wants to upgrade your kitchen's buzzes and beeps

Live

The Wall Street Journal

Newspaper · 2012

The Search for Sweet Sounds That Sell

Live

Co.Design

Article · 2012

GE's New Emphasis In Appliances: Sound Design

Archived · 2012-12

GE Reports

Article · 2012

Beat Is What's For Dinner: Composer Makes GE Washers, Ovens Pitch Perfect

Archived · 2013-09

insideGE

Interview · 2012

Make Some Noise

AI usage

2, Ideas. AI helped with research, sources, brainstorming or structure. I wrote every word.The tiers